Is Carthage or New York City Safer?
According to crimebycity.com's analysis of 2024 FBI data, Carthage is safer than New York City (Safety Score 58/100 vs 19/100), with a total crime rate of 1,460 per 100,000 versus 3,040 for New York City — 52% lower. Carthage has lower rates in 7 of 7 crime categories.
The biggest difference is in murder, where Carthage has a 100% lower rate.
Note: New York City is 533.7x larger by coverage, which can affect crime rate comparisons. Larger cities tend to report higher rates due to density and more comprehensive reporting.
Carthage — 5-Year Trend
Violent
Property
Total
New York City — 5-Year Trend
Violent
Property
Total
Carthage, MO
New York City, NY
Detailed Crime Rate Comparison
| Crime Type | Carthage | New York City | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Crime Rate | 1,459.9 | 3,039.7 | -1,579.8 |
| Violent Crime Rate | 173.6 | 671.4 | -497.8 |
| Murder Rate | 0.0 | 3.9 | -3.9 |
| Rape Rate | 25.7 | 23.4 | +2.3 |
| Robbery Rate | 0.0 | 187.5 | -187.5 |
| Aggravated Assault Rate | 147.9 | 456.2 | -308.3 |
| Property Crime Rate | 1,286.3 | 2,368.3 | -1,082.0 |
| Burglary Rate | 154.4 | 154.7 | -0.4 |
| Larceny-Theft Rate | 1,029.0 | 2,015.0 | -986.0 |
| Motor Vehicle Theft Rate | 102.9 | 198.5 | -95.6 |
All rates per 100,000 residents. Source: FBI UCR 2024.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Carthage or New York City safer?
Carthage is safer with a total crime rate of 1,460 per 100K vs 3,040 for New York City — a 52% difference.
How do violent crime rates compare?
Carthage has a violent crime rate of 173.6 per 100K while New York City has 671.4. Carthage has lower violent crime.
About Carthage, MO
Carthage, Missouri, known as "America's Maple Leaf City," sits in Jasper County. This city of over 15,000 residents is home to the historic Jasper County Courthouse, built with local Carthage stone. With a safety score of 58/100 and a population coverage of 15,549, Carthage has a total crime rate of 1,459.9 per 100,000 residents.
About New York City, NY
New York City, a global financial hub, sits at the mouth of the Hudson River. Home to the iconic Statue of Liberty, its five boroughs house over 8 million people, making it the most populous city in the United States. With a safety score of 19/100 and a population coverage of 8,299,271, New York City has a total crime rate of 3,039.7 per 100,000 residents.