Is Nantucket or New York City Safer?
According to crimebycity.com's analysis of 2024 FBI data, Nantucket is safer than New York City (Safety Score 70/100 vs 19/100), with a total crime rate of 1,116 per 100,000 versus 3,040 for New York City — 63% lower. Nantucket has lower rates in 7 of 7 crime categories.
The biggest difference is in murder, where Nantucket has a 100% lower rate.
Note: New York City is 561.2x larger by coverage, which can affect crime rate comparisons. Larger cities tend to report higher rates due to density and more comprehensive reporting.
Nantucket — 5-Year Trend
Violent
Property
Total
New York City — 5-Year Trend
Violent
Property
Total
Nantucket, MA
New York City, NY
Detailed Crime Rate Comparison
| Crime Type | Nantucket | New York City | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Crime Rate | 1,115.7 | 3,039.7 | -1,924.0 |
| Violent Crime Rate | 202.9 | 671.4 | -468.6 |
| Murder Rate | 0.0 | 3.9 | -3.9 |
| Rape Rate | 40.6 | 23.4 | +17.2 |
| Robbery Rate | 0.0 | 187.5 | -187.5 |
| Aggravated Assault Rate | 162.3 | 456.2 | -293.9 |
| Property Crime Rate | 912.8 | 2,368.3 | -1,455.4 |
| Burglary Rate | 74.4 | 154.7 | -80.4 |
| Larceny-Theft Rate | 791.1 | 2,015.0 | -1,223.9 |
| Motor Vehicle Theft Rate | 47.3 | 198.5 | -151.2 |
All rates per 100,000 residents. Source: FBI UCR 2024.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Nantucket or New York City safer?
Nantucket is safer with a total crime rate of 1,116 per 100K vs 3,040 for New York City — a 63% difference.
How do violent crime rates compare?
Nantucket has a violent crime rate of 202.9 per 100K while New York City has 671.4. Nantucket has lower violent crime.
About Nantucket, MA
Nantucket, a remote island 30 miles south of Cape Cod, was once the whaling capital of the world. Today, its well-preserved historic district and pristine beaches attract a seasonal influx of wealthy summer residents, while year-round inhabitants number around 14,000. With a safety score of 70/100 and a population coverage of 14,789, Nantucket has a total crime rate of 1,115.7 per 100,000 residents.
About New York City, NY
New York City, a global financial hub, sits at the mouth of the Hudson River. Home to the iconic Statue of Liberty, its five boroughs house over 8 million people, making it the most populous city in the United States. With a safety score of 19/100 and a population coverage of 8,299,271, New York City has a total crime rate of 3,039.7 per 100,000 residents.